One of several reviewer’s issues are that publication regarded “my” etcetera as determiners, once they had been in reality (within his advice) pronouns
– I do accept your on keeping words down in the courses, and i offer your one to children tend to be planning to discover what adjectives was than just determiners.
Indeed, In my opinion I just make reference to “my”etcetera since possessives in case your you prefer arises, and therefore is not that commonly (they don’t appear to end up in of a lot harm to Shine learners, no less than). However, direction guides sometimes relate to determiners, so i need to be able to define him or her.
The point I happened to be and come up with to help you Syed Usman is that it is dangerous to talk inside the absolutes inside the code. Just because his words neighborhood and you can exploit refer to “my” an such like as determiners and you may “mine” an such like as the “possessive pronouns” it doesn’t mean that somebody more making reference to “my” an such like because possessive pronouns is actually always wrong. Which is undoubtedly how many linguists reference them, including.
I learned so it the difficult means. I got simply created an article having my personal blog site for the determiners and you can pronouns, as i noticed a rather (unfairly for me) terrible writeup on an EFL sentence structure publication on the a blog having a clearly linguistics angle. As i dared so you’re able to feedback that this is actually absolutely important in the EFL, he cited Huddleston and hongkongcupid you will Pullum in the myself, and i was given a good lecture in the “determinatives” (that we had never observed – neither In my opinion, have many anybody).
While i try rather concerned I’d first got it all completely wrong from inside the my blog post, I did so a little research into the entire determiner / determinative thing (it’s a little bit of in pretty bad shape), hence my personal regard to those two source books. But have you to definitely good idea to my writings, that’s that i make use of the conventional terms from EFL, thus I am sticking with the high quality EFL and you can dictionary definition of determiner I would personally already utilized, and you may leaving this new odd and wonderful articles into the linguists..
We agree. In the event that some one expected what a great determiner was, I’d just give them an inventory. BTW inside the Hungarian, possession is carried out which have noun endings not independent words.
Regardless of how I think of it, ‘Mine and you will Greg’s’ appears to be proper
First, you have the object, the ‘child.’ And after that you have the several possessors, ‘Greg,’ in addition to pronoun to have ‘yourself.’ Dependent on and this person you’re creating for the, the issue on the process may differ. Earliest person is awful having material possessives!
Bring it having a grain off sodium; my super-super-cool qualifications lie in many treacherous and you can unedited regions of Fanfiction; I would not be shocked if i is actually considering it completely in reverse!
And additionally, when in doubt, try saying the sentence out loud. ‘My and you may Greg’s child’ compared to ‘Mine and Greg’s child’–what type tunes better? You are sure that what type I would squeeze into. Only sayin’.
– and there lies an element of the disease: it’s confusing separate away from if or not we fool around with ‘my’ otherwise ‘mine’. (We notice that in my basic feedback I got believed they have been speaking of just one son,but on the 2nd look I’d really believe a couple was getting regarded.
What’s more it looks to me abnormal for factors I pointed out before. The person had currently removed the child/pupils to school, so presumably realized its term(s) – so why not just use its names in place of this a little awkward structure?
In addition I can not agree with Ashley:) – as far as i understand, we very nearly avoid using possessive pronouns before individual or procedure has been stated (except perhaps in book headings). “Greg’s man and you can exploit” could really works, in the event the indeed there a couple of pupils, or more, but “Exploit and you will Greg’s man”? I believe not.